Small Batch Fudge Flavors

Holiday Flavor

How to pick a fudge flavor

If this is your first order, start with Chocolate Walnut or plain Chocolate. If you already know you like fudge, Penuche is the one worth trying next — brown sugar and butter, no chocolate at all.

Most people order four flavors rather than one, which is what the Buy 3 Get 1 Free mix is built for. If you are buying for someone else and are not sure what they like, a mixed box is a safer bet than committing to a single flavor.

Seasonal flavors are made once a year and are not repeated until the following season. If a fall or holiday flavor is on this page right now, it will not be here in a few months.

Fudge questions, answered

What flavors of fudge do you make?

Every flavor we currently make is listed on this page. They fall into a few families: chocolate fudge, caramel and penuche, nut fudge, fruit and cream, seasonal flavors that rotate through fall and the holidays, and a small number of novelty flavors — including dill pickle fudge, which is exactly what it sounds like.

What is penuche fudge?

Penuche is a brown-sugar fudge made with no chocolate at all. Brown sugar, butter, milk and vanilla are cooked together and beaten until the texture turns smooth and slightly grainy. It tastes like caramel or butterscotch rather than chocolate, and it is softer and less sweet than a chocolate fudge. People who say they do not like fudge often mean they do not like chocolate fudge, and penuche is usually the one that changes their mind.

Which fudge flavors are most popular?

Chocolate, Amaretto Chocolate, Peanut Butter Chocolate and Maple Walnut are consistently among our best sellers. In fall and winter the seasonal batches often outsell everything else, and they do sell out.

Can I order fudge in bulk, or for a corporate gift or fundraiser?

Yes. For larger orders and gift programs, see our wholesale and reseller information, or our fundraising program for schools, churches and organizations. For anything that does not fit either one, get in touch and we will work it out with you.

Still not sure which flavor to send?

If you are stuck between flavors, have an allergy question, or need a large order put together for a shop, a fundraiser or a corporate gift, call us at 608-452-2042 or send us a note through our contact page. We would rather talk it through than have you guess.